Seismic Methods: Refraction and Reflection
Like the DC resistivity method, seismic methods, as typically applied in exploration seismology, are considered active geophysical methods. In seismic surveying, ground movement caused by some source* is measured at a variety of distances from the source. The type of seismic experiment differs depending on what aspect of the recorded ground motion is used in the subsequent analysis. We do not mean to imply by this statement that any seismic experiment can be done from a given set of observations. On the contrary, the two types of experiments described below have very different acquisition requirements. These acquisition differences, however, arise from the need to record specific parts of the Earth's ground motion over specific distances.
One of the first active seismic experiments was conducted in 1845 by Robert Mallet, considered by many to be the father of instrumental seismology. Mallet measured the time of transmission of seismic waves, probably surface waves, generated by an explosion. To make this measurement, Mallet placed small containers of mercury at various distances from the source of the explosion and noted the time it took for the surface of the mercury to ripple after the explosion. In 1909, Andrija Mohorovicic used travel-times from earthquake sources to perform a seismic refraction experiment and discovered the existence of the crust-mantle boundary now called the Moho.
The earliest uses of seismic observations for the exploration of oil and mineral resources date back to the 1920s. The seismic refraction technique, described briefly below, was used extensively in Iran to delineate structures that contained oil. The seismic reflection method, now the most commonly used seismic method in the oil industry, was first demonstrated in Oklahoma in 1921. A plaque commemorating this event was erected on the site by the Society of Exploration Geophysicists in 1971.
- Refraction Seismology -Refraction experiments are based on the times of arrival of the initial ground movement generated by a source recorded at a variety of distances. Later arriving complications in the recorded ground motion are discarded. Thus, the data set derived from refraction experiments consists of a series of times versus distances. These are then interpreted in terms of the depths to subsurface interfaces and the speeds at which motion travels through the subsurface within each layer. These speeds are controlled by a set of physical constants, called elastic parameters that describe the material.
- Reflection Seismology - In reflection experiments, analysis is concentrated on energy arriving after the initial ground motion. Specifically, the analysis concentrates on ground movement that has been reflected off of subsurface interfaces. In this sense, reflection seismology is a very sophisticated version of the echo sounding used in submarines, ships, and radar systems. In addition to examining the times of arrival of these, reflection seismic processing extracts information about the subsurface from the amplitude and shape of the ground motion. Subsurface structures can be complex in shape but like the refraction methods, are interpreted in terms of boundaries separating material with differing elastic parameters.
Each of these techniques has specific advantages and disadvantages when compared to each other and when compared to other geophysical techniques. For these reasons, different industries apply these techniques to differing degrees. For example, the oil and gas industries use the seismic reflection technique almost to the exclusion of other geophysical techniques. The environmental and engineering communities use seismic techniques less frequently than other geophysical techniques. When seismic methods are used in these communities, they tend to emphasize the refraction methods over the reflection methods.
*Any of a variety of sources can be used. Typically these sources are manmade, thus satisfying our definition of an active geophysical survey . One could imagine using natural sources like earthquakes. Experiments that use natural sources to generate ground motion, however, are considered passive experiments.
Seismology
- Simple Earth Model: Low-Velocity Layer Over a Halfspacepg 11
- Head Wavespg 12
- Records of Ground Motionpg 13
- Travel-time Curves for a Simple Earth Modelpg 14
- First Arrivalspg 15
- Determining Earth Structure from Travel Timespg 16
- Derivation of Travel Time Equationspg 17
- High-Velocity Layer Over a Halfspace: Reprisepg 18
- Picking Times of Arrivalspg 25
- Wave Propagation with Multiple Horizontal Layerspg 26
- Travel Time Curves from Multiple Horizontalpg 27
- Hidden Layerspg 28
- Head Waves from a Dipping Layer: Shooting Down Dippg 29
- Head Waves from a Dipping Layer: Shooting Up Dippg 30
- A Field Procedure for Recognizing Dipping Bedspg 31
- Estimating Dips and Depths from Travelpg 32